Montauk Manor

The Resort & Setting

Montauk Manor occupies a 1927 building in Montauk, Suffolk County, on the easternmost stretch of Long Island. It's run as a casual condo hotel, with owners and guests sharing access to a spa, tennis courts, on-site dining, and both indoor and outdoor pools. The property holds a strong 4.5/5 rating from over 1,279 Google reviews, a solid signal for anyone researching the resort before buying, selling or booking a stay. The address, 236 Edgemere Street, puts it within easy reach of the village centre and the beach, without being right in the thick of the summer crowds.

The Area & Things to Do

Montauk has long traded on its fishing heritage and laid-back coastal character, and that's still what draws people here rather than to the busier Hamptons towns further west. Montauk Downtown, about a kilometre from the resort, has the restaurants, shops, galleries and working fishing dock that give the town its identity. Montauk Beach, roughly 2km away, is the spot for swimming and surfing, while Camp Hero State Park (around 3km) offers coastal hiking trails and ocean overlooks. Further out, the Montauk Point Lighthouse marks the literal end of Long Island and is worth the short drive for the views and maritime history alone. Summer is peak season for beach life and fishing charters; spring and autumn bring quieter streets, cooler air and, in autumn, good foliage.

Selling or Renting a Week Here

Montauk Manor is an independent resort, not part of a branded vacation ownership chain, so resale and rental here work differently than at a branded-exchange property. On BidMyTimeshare, owners list their week directly: you set your own asking price, there's no commission taken from a sale or rental, and interested buyers or renters contact you straight through the platform. You pay a one-time listing fee to get your week in front of buyers — nothing more is deducted when it sells.

Because the resort isn't tied to a branded exchange company, any transfer of ownership is handled through Montauk Manor's own owners' association or on-site management rather than a third-party exchange network. If you're selling, it's worth having your transfer fee and current annual maintenance fee in hand before you agree on a price, since buyers will ask. If you're buying a resale week, confirm with the resort directly what the transfer process involves, how long it typically takes to complete, and exactly what passes to you as the new owner — some privileges tied to the original purchase may not automatically transfer with a resale. We haven't been able to verify any exchange network affiliation for this resort, so don't assume one is included unless the seller or resort confirms it in writing.

Practical Notes

Montauk is best explored by car — distances between the beach, the lighthouse and the village add up quickly, even though Montauk Downtown itself is walkable. Expect the weather to shift with the coast, so pack layers regardless of season, and bring sun protection for beach days. Booking restaurants and water activities ahead of time is sensible in July and August, when the town fills up; spring and autumn are easier-going if you'd rather avoid the crowds.

Who Rents a Week Like This

Renters drawn to Montauk Manor are typically after a beach base with some resort comforts attached — the pools, spa and tennis courts set it apart from a plain motel stay, while the 1927 building gives it a bit more character than a standard condo block. Families and couples looking for a Hamptons-adjacent getaway without Hamptons prices are a natural fit, and the shoulder seasons tend to appeal to renters who want the coastal scenery without the peak summer rates and crowds.